KILN

Home / Supplier survey and selection

Supplier survey and selection consulting

A side-by-side view of primary container manufacturers, CMOs, CPOs and device suppliers, so that supplier selection rests on what each can deliver for your program.

Why supplier choices are hard to undo

A combination product depends on a chain of suppliers: the primary container, the device, fill and finish, final assembly and packaging. Each choice narrows the next.

A syringe that suits the formulation may not run on a particular filling line. A device platform may be qualified with one container and not another. Changing any of these after design verification or a filing usually means repeating work.

We survey the options and compare them against your program's requirements before you commit. Where data would settle the question, shortlisted containers and devices can be tested side by side in our lab.

  1. Primary containerSyringe, cartridge, stopper
  2. DevicePlatform or custom
  3. Fill and finishCMO
  4. Assembly and packagingCMO or CPO
The supply chain of a combination product. Each choice limits the options at the next step.

What we survey

The survey is built around your product, not a generic vendor list.

Supplier categories

The four groups most combination product programs need to choose from.

Primary container manufacturers

Syringe, cartridge and plunger stopper options for your formulation and device: glass or polymer, formats and sizes, and how each fits the rest of the system.

  • Syringes
  • Cartridges
  • Stoppers

Device suppliers

Autoinjectors, pen injectors, needle safety devices, on-body injectors and other delivery devices, platform or custom, compared against your dose, viscosity and user requirements.

  • Platform vs. custom
  • Device fit

Contract manufacturing organizations (CMOs)

Fill and finish and device assembly partners, compared on whether they can run your container and device combination.

  • Fill and finish
  • Assembly

Contract packaging organizations (CPOs)

Packaging partners for the finished combination product.

  • Packaging

How the comparison is built

From requirements to a decision you can defend.

Requirements first

We start by writing down what the program needs from each supplier: technical fit, compatibility with the rest of the chain, and the points that matter most to your team.

  • Requirements
  • Compatibility

Side-by-side comparison

Every option is compared against the same requirements, so that differences are visible and the basis for the choice is on paper.

  • Supplier survey
  • Comparison

Risks flagged

For each option we note the risks we see from testing and development experience, before you commit.

  • Risk assessment

Data where it helps

Shortlisted containers and devices can be evaluated side by side with your formulation, for example as a matrix of syringe and stopper options. See ISO 11040 testing and ISO 11608 testing.

  • Lab evaluation
  • Second sourcing

How we work

Work is structured in phases with clear deliverables at each gate, so you always know what you have paid for and what comes next.

  1. Scope

    We review the product, the program stage and which supplier decisions are open.

  2. Define

    Requirements for each supplier category are written down and agreed with your team.

  3. Survey

    Supplier offerings are gathered and compared against those requirements.

  4. Compare

    Options are laid out side by side, with risks and open questions noted for each.

  5. Recommend

    You receive the comparison and, if you want one, a recommendation. Shortlisted options can go on to lab evaluation.

Deliverables

Deliverables are defined in the proposal before work starts. A typical engagement includes the following.

Requirements listWhat the program needs from each supplier category
Supplier comparisonOptions side by side against the same requirements
Risk notesThe risks and open questions we see for each option
RecommendationIf you want one, with the reasoning written out

Related services

ISO 11040 testingComponent and finished-syringe testing for prefilled syringes and cartridges
ISO 11608 testingDesign verification for pens, autoinjectors and other needle-based injection systems
Device assembly and packagingDevelopment builds with force and torque monitored on every unit
Filling and surrogate solutionsSmall-scale filling at nominal and process extremes, with matched surrogates
Devices we supportPrefilled syringes, cartridges, autoinjectors, pens, wearables and more

Questions we hear often

If yours isn't here, it's a good thing to bring to a consultation.

What types of suppliers do you survey?

Primary container manufacturers, contract manufacturing organizations (CMOs), contract packaging organizations (CPOs) and device suppliers.

Is Kiln tied to any supplier?

We are platform-independent and work with components and devices from any supplier.

Can you test the shortlisted options?

Yes. Candidate syringes, cartridges, stoppers and devices can be evaluated side by side in our lab with your formulation, so the final choice is supported by data.

When should supplier selection start?

As early as primary container selection. The container and device choices constrain which fill and finish and assembly partners can run your product, so it helps to look at the supply chain as a whole before committing to any one part.

How do you handle confidentiality?

We're happy to sign your NDA before any technical discussion. We never disclose client names, products or project details.

Choosing suppliers?

Tell us about the product and which decisions are open. We'll set up a call to talk through what a survey would cover.

Prefer email? Write to info@kiln-lab.com or call +1 (866) 350-8240.